What Is a Real Managed Service Provider (MSP)—And What’s Not?

Home » Uncategorized » What Is a Real Managed Service Provider (MSP)—And What’s Not?

Choosing the right IT partner is critical to the success and security of your business. But with so many companies calling themselves managed service providers (MSPs)—and offering drastically different levels of service—how do you know who’s legitimate?

Even more confusing, some IT vendors make bold claims about their capabilities, but a closer look reveals they’re doing the bare minimum. Protecting your network, patching your systems, and backing up your data are essential basics, not differentiators.

Here’s what you need to know to separate the real MSPs from the pretenders—and why those rock-bottom prices should make you think twice.


What Is a Real MSP?

A mature MSP is more than a service provider—they’re a strategic partner who delivers ongoing IT management, security, and strategic guidance designed to drive your business forward. Real MSPs go far beyond the basics to ensure your IT environment operates smoothly, securely, and efficiently.

Key Traits of a Real MSP

  1. Proactive and Predictive Support
    Mature MSPs monitor your IT systems around the clock, identifying and resolving potential issues before they cause disruptions. This includes performance optimization, predictive analytics, and proactive updates that keep your systems running at peak efficiency.
  2. Comprehensive Cybersecurity
    A true MSP goes well beyond firewalls and antivirus software. They implement multi-layered security, including endpoint detection and response (EDR), security awareness training, vulnerability management, and more to protect against advanced threats.
  3. Strategic IT Roadmapping
    A mature MSP takes time to understand your business goals and develops an IT strategy tailored to your growth. This includes planning for scalability, budgeting for future needs, and ensuring your technology aligns with your business objectives.
  4. Transparent, Flat-Rate Pricing
    Real MSPs offer predictable monthly pricing with no surprises. Their all-inclusive model covers everything from help desk support to advanced cybersecurity, making it easier to budget and plan.
  5. Business Partnership Mentality
    They aren’t just a vendor—they’re an extension of your team, providing insight, guidance, and personalized service.

What’s NOT a Managed Service Provider?

Far too often, IT companies claim to be MSPs while offering services that fall short. If your IT vendor is only focused on doing the bare minimum, they’re not a true MSP.

Basic IT Vendors vs. Real MSPs

When an IT company says things like:

  • “We protect your network.”
  • “We patch your systems.”
  • “We back up your data.”
  • “We’re proactive.”

…you should take a step back. These are the basics—table stakes in today’s IT landscape. While these services are important, they are the bare minimum expected from any IT provider, not differentiators that set an MSP apart.

The Bare Minimum Approach

Basic IT vendors often operate with a “set it and forget it” mentality. They may install a firewall, set up automated backups, and perform occasional patches, but their involvement ends there. This approach leaves your business vulnerable to:

  • Emerging threats: Without layered, proactive cybersecurity, your business is at risk.
  • Downtime: Basic monitoring doesn’t prevent or predict failures.
  • Missed opportunities: Without a strategic partner, your IT infrastructure isn’t aligned with your business goals.

The Danger of “Cheap” MSPs

Another major red flag is MSPs offering suspiciously low prices. While affordability is important, ultra-cheap IT providers often deliver inadequate service that puts your business at risk.

Why Cheap MSPs Are a Problem

  1. They’re Barely Breaking Even
    A mature MSP invests heavily in tools, training, and staff to deliver reliable service. If an MSP’s pricing seems too good to be true, they’re likely cutting corners. This often means:
    • No 24/7 monitoring
    • Limited cybersecurity tools
    • Understaffed teams unable to meet client demands
  2. They’re Reactive, Not Proactive
    Low-cost providers often skip proactive measures like predictive analytics or strategic planning, focusing only on fixing problems after they occur. This reactive approach leads to:
    • Extended downtime
    • Higher repair costs
    • Frustration for your team
  3. They Don’t Offer Strategic Guidance
    Cheap MSPs tend to provide cookie-cutter solutions instead of tailored strategies to help your business grow.
  4. They Overload Their Staff
    To stay afloat, cheap MSPs often take on too many clients, leaving their team stretched thin and unable to provide high-quality service.
  5. They Put Security at Risk
    With limited budgets, low-cost MSPs can’t afford advanced cybersecurity tools or experts, leaving your systems vulnerable to threats.

How to Spot a Real MSP

To identify a genuine MSP, ask these critical questions:

  • What’s included in your pricing? A mature MSP offers transparent, flat-rate pricing that covers comprehensive services—not just the basics.
  • How do you handle cybersecurity? Look for multi-layered protections, regular assessments, and incident response planning.
  • What’s your approach to IT strategy? Real MSPs invest time in understanding your business and aligning IT with your goals.
  • How do you staff your team? Ask about team size, certifications, and their ability to respond quickly to issues.

The Bottom Line

If your IT vendor is only focused on patching systems, protecting your network, and backing up your data, they’re just doing the bare minimum. A true MSP goes far beyond that, becoming a proactive, strategic partner dedicated to your success.

At Schilling IT, we believe businesses deserve more than basic IT. That’s why we offer comprehensive, proactive, and transparent managed services designed to help you grow and thrive.

Ready to experience the difference a real MSP can make? Let’s talk.


By understanding what separates real MSPs from the pretenders, you can make smarter decisions about your IT partnership—ones that drive your business forward instead of holding it back. Don’t settle for the bare minimum.

Fill in our contact form and our team will reach out!

"*" indicates required fields

Let's make a difference when it comes to your tech support.

Contact us today to get started!

90356436_3258939227467623_1462429479455424512_n

"Great customer service, and quick!!! Total professionalism on appearance and demeanor. Completely satisfied with the work we had performed.”

KERRY DRAKE
MAINTENANCE MANAGER AT LIVING STONES CHURCH IN CROWN POINT, INDIANA

Your Local IT Experts

How We Help Your Business

Fully Managed IT Solutions

As Technology becomes more complex, it’s increasingly important to apply a best-practices approach to managing your IT.

Business Communications

The strategic deployment of VoIP can be done either as an independent service or seamlessly integrated with video conferencing technologies.

Cloud Technologies

Schilling IT specializes in cloud services and cloud solutions for organizations throughout Northwest Indiana and the Chicagoland area.

Cybersecurity & Risk Management

Aligning IT infrastructure with the demands of regulatory compliance and Cyber Insurance requirements, which may encompass services like HIPAA to meet business needs.

IT Roadmap

As your business expands and evolves, the role of IT within your organization becomes increasingly critical. We strategically design a roadmap and budget plan for your IT.

Microsoft Office 365

Unlocking the full potential of your 365 subscription through effective digital transformation. Enhancing cloud access, seamless collaboration, server reduction, and remote work enablement.

Co-Managed IT

By Supplementing your existing IT team with resources from Schilling IT, your team will avoid burnout and experience peace of mind.

Managed Apple IT

Effortlessly managing your Mac technology, on par with Windows systems, for your small and medium business.